top of page

Custom Cookie Creations

Hosting a special event and need something that'll leave a lasting impression on your guests?  Tell us about it and let's get baking!  Kay is a self-taught cookie decorator who enjoys the challenge of creating unique designs, pushing the limits of cookie science.  Birthdays, graduations, weddings, anniversaries, announcements, corporate events, holidays, etc., are just a few of the occasions her portfolio includes.  Don't see what you want...use the contact link above and Kay will customize a design.

The Truth About Custom Cookies

Baker's Confession:     Custom Cookies cost more money, plain and simple.

It's a luxury item made by a passionate Gal that puts her heart and soul into every unique order. A sincere Thank You to all my clients for supporting the quality product of an individual artisan.  I am humbled at the consistent growth of my cookie business.

                             Sincerely, Kay

Not Enough Dough Cookies is located in Westfield, Indiana, as a Home Based Vendor, i.e., HB-1149.


  • All designs have a minimum order of 4 dozen.

  • Designed and decorated cookies start at $45 per dozen and can be more depending on complexity.  


The amount of decorating details, the size of the cookie, and complexity of the design is what ultimately determines the final price of your cookies.  I put a lot of effort, thought and time into making sure your cookies are made just for you.  Each cookie is made to order and I use a flavorful royal icing as a base coat and then hand decorate them one at a time.

Ordering and Availability:

I may or may not be able to accommodate your order without substantial lead time, no matter how small.  Ordering is best by completing and submitting the Order Form on this site.  I am generally booked 4 to 6 weeks out.  A 50% non-refundable deposit is required at time of ordering.  Once the design has been agreed upon, I will send a confirmation to you via email.  No changes can be accepted after that.  Photos of my cookies can be seen on this website and also on our Instagram & Facebook pages through the links below.  Cookies are packaged individually in food safe cello bags.

Cookie Ingredients:  flour, butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla, confectioner's sugar, corn syrup, meringue mix, glycerin, salt, gel colorings.

Not Enough Dough Cookies


bottom of page