Custom Cookie Creations

Hosting a special event and need something that'll leave a lasting impression on your guests?  Tell us about it and let's get baking!  Kay is a self-taught cookie decorator who enjoys the challenge of creating unique designs, pushing the limits of cookie science.  Birthdays, graduations, weddings, anniversaries, announcements, corporate events, holidays, etc., are just a few of the occasions her portfolio includes.  Don't see what you want...use the contact link above and Kay will customize a design.

The Truth About Custom Cookies

Baker's Confession:     Custom Cookies cost more money, plain and simple.

It's a luxury item made by a passionate Gal that puts her heart and soul into every unique order. A sincere Thank You to all my clients for supporting the quality product of an individual artisan.  I am humbled at the consistent growth of my cookie business.

                             Sincerely, Kay

Not Enough Dough Cookies is located in Westfield, Indiana, as a Home Based Vendor, i.e., HEA 1309.


  • All designs have a minimum order of 2 dozen.

  • Designed and decorated cookies start at $36 per dozen.  


The amount of decorating details, the size of the cookie, and complexity of the design is what ultimately determines the final price of your cookies.  I put a lot of effort, thought and time into making sure your cookies are made just for you.  Each cookie is made to order and I use a flavorful royal icing as a base coat and then hand decorate them one at a time.  They come in all shapes and sizes for showers, weddings, birthdays, sports, thank you gifts, bereavement, and any occasion.

Ordering and Availability:
I may or may not be able to accommodate your order without substantial lead time, no matter how small.  Ordering by phone is best (317-431-3135).  I am generally booked 4 to 6 weeks out.  A 50% non-refundable deposit is required at time of ordering.  Once the design has been agreed upon, I will send a confirmation to you via email.  No changes can be accepted after that.  Photos of my cookies can be seen on this website and also on our Instagram & Facebook pages through the links below.  Cookies are packaged individually in food safe cello bags.

Cookie Ingredients:  flour, butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla, confectioner's sugar, corn syrup, meringue mix, glycerin, salt, gel colorings.

Not Enough Dough Cookies